No Photography Allowed

When we were recently at the Phoenix Art Museum, I briefly stepped outside into the Dorrance Sculpture Garden (funded by Valley resident and Campbell Soup heir Bennett Dorrance and his wife Jacquie) and photographed this sculpture. Not until I came back in did Tony show me the “No Photography Allowed” sign for the garden. Oh, well, the guard was right there and saw me so I don’t feel too bad. I knew photography inside the museum is not allowed but I didn’t really think of it as applying to outdoor pieces.

Have you seen or read about this sculpture before? It is famous/notorious/controversial. It is called Tumbling Woman by Eric Fischl and was meant to commemorate those who jumped or fell to their deaths from the World Trade Center on 9/11 and was displayed in Rockefeller Center in 2009 (eight years later). It caused so much controversy from people who found it offensive that it was first draped and then removed. In turn, the removal of the sculpture caused outrage in those who felt it was an important piece.

“The sculpture was not meant to hurt anybody,” Fischl said in a statement. “It was a sincere expression of deepest sympathy for the vulnerability of the human condition. Both specifically towards the victims of September 11 and towards humanity in general.”

A poem by Fischl, which appeared on a plaque near the sculpture, read:

“We watched,
disbelieving and helpless,
on that savage day.
People we love
began falling,
helpless and in disbelief.”

I don’t personally find it offensive but I also didn’t personally know anyone who died that day and almost 10 years have now passed. Does it upset or disturb you? I think oftentimes that art is meant to provoke discussion and strong emotions.

I don’t know if this is the specific sculpture that was displayed in NYC as I read that five editions were cast. The plaque by this one says it is on loan from the GUC Collection.

My favorite piece at the museum in recent years is no longer on display. The security guard told us it’s part of the permanent collection so hopefully it will resurface again. This one I have known better than to photograph as it had a sign right next to it stating no photography allowed. It is called The Embrace by Patricia Piccinini (photo from here). It’s pretty thought-provoking, too, in a different way.

7 thoughts on “No Photography Allowed

  1. I had no idea that the piece ever found a home. i thought it was destroyed. I thought it was horrible myself. Although I am sure it came from a deep place of pain inside of the artist. But still…it was too much at that time to look at.


  2. A very interesting post of the sculptures and the varied opinions of these works. I find them provocative in that they make one think…and think again.


  3. wow .. we had a similar issue in my area,, sculpture that people perceived to be something it is not.. It finally found a home in a different spot..I do think art does that to people that is the joy of it ..the feelings it brings forth..good or bad

    i have missed visiting your~blessings


  4. I’m on the fence about the statue. It makes me uncomfortable looking at it, imagining the impact and all….it’s very tragic and distressing. I think we’re all used to thinking of figural statues as being heroic in a greek and roman way…and the Tumbling Woman isn’t at all. Not that it has to be!


  5. I usually enter on the side right across the sculpture garden when you enter a large panoramic area of their cycled modern art with the open upstairs area which is usually blocked off for the extra special exhibits. From there you start seeing some more European sculptures and a hallway to your right you may enter into some nice areas as well.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s